Score: 10

"Typically briallant."

submission: Just another Sunday

date: March 8, 2005

Once again, VVithereD you have put the other portal submissions to shame and now you have given every one of the stick tweeners a burn that should sting for awhile. Good job!

Score: 10

"This is the best flash I've seen."

submission: how it will end.

date: March 5, 2005

I know you probably don't read reviews for this one anymore, Mr. BOX, but here goes anyway...

Holy crap!
After watching glenn said for the February competition (I did wind up voting it 1st, by the way) I wanted to check out some more of your content. Since this is the highest scoring one I thought I would watch it first.

The score of 4.19 is very well deserved (though it could and should be higher) as this is the single best flash I've ever seen. Funny as hell and just as surreal it made me feel emotions that I usually don't and the confusion that I often do.

I love it.

(...and my dad IS a zombie...)

-Kraig

Score: 10

"This is awesome!"

submission: glenn said

date: March 1, 2005

Thanks for making such a great flash.

Graphically stunning, with excellent color choices, great music and flow. AND WITH MEANING, which is something rare and beautiful to find. Keep up the fantastic work. I hope to view your other submissions as soon as I get through looking at the rest of the Feburary submissions (most likely this is getting my top vote).

Score: 9

"Power Stone music!!"

submission: Mr Shibby"Shaolin Soccer"

date: February 25, 2005

I don't know jack about Shaolin Soccer. But I do know Capcom's Power Stone games and the fact that you used the music makes me happy. ^_^

Oh yeah, the art and animation and everything else was very well done.

Score: 7

"Really good..."

submission: Robot Desire

date: February 22, 2005

I really liked this... the graphics were well made and consistant. The mood was melancholy... always a plus for me. I love the way the backgrounds looked and the way the movie was paced as well.

I would have given this a nine, but the sound was a bit too loud. And by a bit I mean I think it permanantly damaged my hearing. :P
You should put up a disclaimer for viewers to turn down their volume before watching.

But it's a great submission nonetheless, and I hope to see more from you in the future! :D

Score: 9

"I love these. Keep making them!"

submission: Nurse.

date: February 21, 2005

VVithered, you are a true artist. Your art style, animation and color use are fantastic.

Sure, it's a little weird and difficult to follow, but that, in my opinion, only add to the abstractness and appeal of this flash.

Keep it up!
:D

Score: 9

"That was spectacular."

submission: -Obsolete-

date: February 20, 2005

This submission was fantastic. The sound was really great, the animation was very smooth, and the graphics were consistant throughout.

You have inspired me to get back to work on my flash with a robot in it.
<(^.^<)

Awesome!

Score: 9

"I enjoyed this quite a bit..."

submission: Noah - A Short Film

date: February 15, 2005

...and I would just like to say that It really does not matter who interprets this in what way.

Everones mind is as unique as their fingerprints, and will experience something in their own way. And while I think I have *some* idea as to the intended meaning of this flash I can never know completely as I am not it's creator.

Art should be judged on it's merits, not on whether or not you think you "get it."

Hugs for everyone! I've been drinking. :)

Score: 8

"Don't... worry..? Be... happy..?"

submission: Dancing Animals

date: February 3, 2005

Those are two things I don't usually do, and this cartoon caused me to do both, quite a bit! :D

Keep it up. I love the animals, especially the cat, she's my favorite.

Score: 8

"Awww!"

submission: Shyguy's Flower

date: February 2, 2005

It was cute and sweet and the colors were great... but was the naration really necessary? I think the story was told pretty well by just the animation and I found reading it kind of distracting.

Still it was great. ^_^